How to sell a coin collection

A step-by-step plan for sorting, valuing and selling a coin collection, so you know which coins are worth metal and which deserve a closer look.

Quick answer

Sort the collection into bullion, silver and gold coins worth their metal, and coins that might be worth more to collectors. Work out melt value first, get collector opinions only on the coins that need them, and compare offers from more than one buyer.

Start by not changing anything

Whether you built the collection yourself or inherited it, the first rule is the same: leave the coins as they are. Keep them in their holders, folders, albums and original Mint packaging.

  • Don’t clean them. The US Mint says “polishing and/or cleaning coins can reduce their value.” See should you clean coins before selling?
  • Handle coins by the edges. The Mint suggests holding a coin “by its edges between your thumb and forefinger over a soft towel.”
  • Don’t break up sets. A sealed proof set or a filled album often sells better as it is. See US Mint proof and mint sets.

Step 1: Make a rough inventory

You don’t need to be an expert. A simple list in a notebook or spreadsheet is enough. For each coin or group, write down:

  • Country and denomination (for example, US quarter)
  • Date and mint mark (a small letter such as D, S, O or CC)
  • How many you have
  • Whether it’s loose, in a folder, in Mint packaging or in a sealed grading holder (a “slab”)

Big lots of similar coins can be counted as a group, such as “40 Roosevelt dimes, 1946–1964.”

Step 2: Sort into three piles

Most collections fall into three groups, and each one is sold differently.

Pile Examples What sets the price
Bullion Silver Eagles, Maple Leafs, Krugerrands, silver rounds and bars Metal content, close to the spot price
Common silver and gold coins Worn 90% silver dimes, quarters and halves; 40% silver Kennedy halves; common-date gold Mostly metal content
Possible collector coins Pre-1933 US gold, Morgan and Peace dollars, older dates, coins in slabs, high-grade coins Collector demand, which can be well above metal value

Coins with no precious metal, like most modern clad quarters, usually belong in a fourth pile worth face value, unless they’re unusual.

To check which coins contain silver, see how to tell if a coin is silver and 40% and 35% silver coins.

Step 3: Work out melt value

Melt value is what the metal in a coin is worth at today’s price. It gives you a floor: for coins with silver or gold, a fair offer usually shouldn’t be far below it.

Buyers usually pay somewhat less than full melt value, since they need a margin to cover costs and resale. How much less varies by buyer and by coin.

Step 4: Check the possible collector coins

Only the third pile needs a closer look. Use our What’s my coin worth? finder for rough values of worn US coins, and see melt value vs collector value for signs a coin may be worth more than its metal.

Condition matters a lot for these coins. Our guide to coin grading and slabs explains what grades like F-12 or MS-65 mean. For anything that looks valuable, get an opinion from more than one coin dealer before you sell. The Minnesota Attorney General advises getting “a second opinion about the grade and value of the coins.”

Price guides show retail prices. Dealers usually pay less than those numbers, because they need to resell.

Step 5: Choose how to sell

  • Local coin shop. Fast, and you can watch the coins being examined and counted. Ask for prices per group, not just one number for everything.
  • Selling to several buyers. You might sell bullion to one buyer and collector coins to another, if that gets better prices.
  • Auctions or consignment. Can make sense for scarce or high-value coins, but fees apply and payment takes longer.
  • Selling online yourself. Possible, but it takes time and you carry the risk of shipping and fraud. See staying safe when selling gold.

Whatever route you pick, take photos and keep your inventory list, so you can check that everything you sent or handed over is accounted for.

Taxes on the sale

In the US, coins are treated as collectibles. The IRS says “net capital gains from selling collectibles (such as coins or art) are taxed at a maximum 28% rate.” Coins held for more than a year generally count as long-term.

If you inherited the coins, the IRS says your starting value (your “basis”) is generally their fair market value on the date the person died. That can make a big difference to any gain. See taxes when you sell gold and inherited gold and coins, and ask a tax professional about your own situation.

Values on this site are estimates, not offers, and this guide is not financial, tax or legal advice.

Sources

Last reviewed November 11, 2026. This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Was this guide helpful?

Keep reading

All guides →