Native American silver and turquoise jewelry: what is it worth?

How to value silver and turquoise jewelry, why the silver weight is only the floor, and what the law says about calling a piece Native American made.

Quick answer

The silver in a turquoise piece sets a floor price: weigh it, subtract the stones, and use the silver calculator. A piece made by a known Native American artist, or an older piece with collector interest, can be worth far more than its silver, so get it looked at before you sell it for scrap.

Two kinds of value

Silver and turquoise jewelry, such as cuffs, squash blossom necklaces, concho belts and rings, often turns up in inherited jewelry boxes. It can be worth money in two very different ways:

  • Melt value. The silver in the piece, at today’s silver price. This is the floor.
  • Collector or resale value. What someone will pay for the piece as jewelry, because of who made it, how old it is, the quality of the stones and the work.

For a lot of souvenir jewelry, melt value is close to what it is worth. For a signed piece by a known Native American artist, or a well-made older piece, the resale value can be much higher. Selling that kind of piece for scrap throws most of its value away.

Check the silver first

Turn the piece over and look for marks. Common ones are:

Mark What it usually means
Sterling, Ster. or 925 At least 92.5% silver
Coin or Coin Silver At least 90% silver
Initials, a name or a symbol The maker’s hallmark, not the purity
No mark Could be silver, could be something else

The Federal Trade Commission’s jewelry guides say “sterling” should only be used for silver that is at least 925 parts per thousand pure, and “coin silver” for at least 900. They also say silver-plated items should not be stamped “sterling” or “coin.”

Many older pieces carry no purity mark at all, only a maker’s mark or nothing. That doesn’t mean they aren’t silver, but a buyer will want to test them. A buyer can test with acid or an XRF analyzer, a machine that reads the metals without damaging the piece. See how buyers test your gold; the same methods work for silver.

Work out the melt value

The turquoise and other stones add weight but no silver value, so they need to come off the total.

  1. Weigh the whole piece in grams. A scale that reads to 0.01 g is best for rings and earrings. See how to weigh gold at home; the same steps work for silver.
  2. Estimate the stone weight. Large stones in a heavy setting can be a real share of the weight. If you can’t remove them, make a cautious guess, or ask the buyer how they will deduct them.
  3. Open the silver calculator, choose .925 for sterling, and enter the silver weight.

For more on pieces with stones, see gold with stones; the same idea applies to silver. Scrap buyers usually pay a share of melt value, not all of it.

What can make a piece worth more

These are the things people who deal in this jewelry usually look at:

  • A maker’s hallmark. Many Native American silversmiths stamp their work with initials, a name or a symbol. A mark from a well-known artist can raise the value a lot.
  • Age. Older pieces from the first half of the 1900s can attract collectors.
  • The stones. Natural turquoise from a known mine can be worth more than stones that have been treated or stabilized (soaked with a resin to harden them), or reconstituted from crushed turquoise. Some “turquoise” is a dyed different stone or plastic. Telling them apart takes a trained eye or a lab.
  • The work. Hand-stamped designs, careful stone settings and heavy, solid construction usually count for more than thin, mass-made pieces.

None of this changes the melt value. It changes what a collector, an antique dealer or an auction house might pay.

Native American made: what the law says

The Indian Arts and Crafts Act of 1990 is a US truth-in-advertising law. The Interior Department’s Indian Arts and Crafts Board explains that it is illegal to offer or sell a product in a way that falsely suggests it was made by a Native American, or by a member of a particular tribe. Under the Act, that means a member of a federally or officially state-recognized tribe, or an artisan certified by a tribe.

The Board says penalties for a first offense can include fines of up to $250,000 and up to five years in prison for an individual, and fines of up to $1 million for a business, depending on the size of the sale.

What this means for you as a seller:

  • Only describe a piece as Native American made, or name a tribe, if you can back it up, for example with a receipt, a written guarantee from the original seller, or a confirmed artist’s hallmark.
  • If you don’t know, say so. “Southwest style” or “silver and turquoise” describes the piece without making a claim you can’t support.

The Board’s own advice to buyers is to ask for written verification that a piece is authentic Native American work. If you have that paperwork from when the piece was bought, keep it with the jewelry. This is general information, not legal advice.

Where to get it valued

Before you sell for melt, get an opinion from someone who knows this kind of jewelry, such as an antique or vintage jewelry dealer, an appraiser or an auction house. Then get a scrap quote too, so you know the floor. If the offers for the piece as jewelry aren’t much higher than melt, selling for the silver may be the simpler choice.

For more on selling silver jewelry in general, see selling sterling silver jewelry.

Quick summary

  • The silver sets the floor: weigh the piece, subtract the stones, and use the silver calculator.
  • Maker’s marks, age, natural stones and good work can make a piece worth much more than its silver.
  • Only call a piece Native American made if you can support it.
  • Get a collector opinion before you sell for scrap.

These figures are estimates, not offers. Buyers set their own prices.

Sources

Last reviewed November 15, 2026. This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Was this guide helpful?

Keep reading

All guides →