Coin silver spoons and flatware from the 1800s

What American coin silver is, how to recognize old coin silver spoons and forks, and how to estimate their silver value before you sell.

Quick answer

Coin silver is American silverware made in the 1700s and 1800s, often from melted coins, before makers moved to the sterling standard. It's usually a little less pure than sterling, so treat it as roughly 90% silver for an estimate, and check for a known maker before you sell it by weight.

What coin silver is

Coin silver is the name for American silverware made before most makers used the sterling standard. Silversmiths often made it by melting down silver coins, so the metal was about as pure as the coins of the day rather than following one fixed standard.

Sotheby’s describes American silver from before about 1871 as often called coin silver, “as it was made by melting down coins”. Tiffany & Co. says it adopted the English sterling standard (925 parts silver per 1,000) well before it became the standard in the United States. Over the second half of the 1800s, most American makers moved to sterling.

So if you have old American spoons, forks or ladles that came down through a family, there’s a good chance some of them are coin silver.

Coin silver vs sterling vs plate

Type Typical marks Silver content
Sterling STERLING, 925 92.5%
Coin silver COIN, a maker’s name, or no purity mark Usually around 90%, but it varies
Silver plate EP, EPNS, A1, “silverplate” A thin coat only

Today, the Federal Trade Commission’s jewelry guides say an item should be called “coin silver” only if it’s at least 900 parts per thousand silver. They also say silver-plated items shouldn’t be stamped “sterling” or “coin”. Pieces made in the early 1800s came long before those guides, so their purity can be a little higher or lower than 90%.

For more on plate marks, see silver plate marks: EPNS, quadruple plate and what they’re worth.

How to recognize coin silver

Look on the back of the handle. Coin silver flatware is usually marked there, if it’s marked at all. You may see:

  • The word COIN, sometimes with other words.
  • A maker’s name or initials. Many pieces have only this.

Unlike British silver, old American silver usually doesn’t carry a full row of official assay marks, so a single maker’s mark is normal. If you see British-style marks, compare them with reading British and European hallmarks to rule out a British piece.

Look at the weight. Early coin silver spoons are often thin and feel light for their size.

Look for a monogram. Old American silver very often has initials or names engraved on the handle. Sotheby’s notes that pieces where an old engraving has been removed are often discounted by collectors.

Rule out other metals. A piece with no purity mark could also be plate, nickel silver or pewter. A magnet test helps a little (silver isn’t magnetic), but it can’t tell coin silver from plated brass. See is my coin silver? for simple checks, and look up any mark in the stamp decoder.

Working out the silver value

  1. Sort your pieces. Put marked sterling, coin silver and plate in separate piles.
  2. Weigh the coin silver in grams on a scale that reads to 0.1 gram. See how to weigh gold at home, which works the same way for silver.
  3. Enter the weight in the silver calculator and choose Coin .900.

Because the purity of old coin silver varies, treat the result as an estimate. Most buyers test it before they make an offer. Many will pay a little less per gram than for sterling, because of the lower and less certain purity.

Most coin silver spoons and forks are solid silver all the way through. If you have knives or serving pieces with hollow handles, these may be filled with other material, the same as with sterling flatware.

When it’s worth more than its silver

Coin silver is old, and some pieces sell for far more as antiques than as scrap. Things that can add value:

  • A known maker. Spoons by recognized early American silversmiths, or by makers from a particular town or region, interest collectors.
  • Clear marks. A sharp, readable maker’s mark matters to buyers who collect by maker.
  • Unusual pieces. Serving pieces such as ladles, sugar tongs and fish slices are less common than teaspoons.
  • Good condition. No splits, heavy dents or worn-through bowls.

A plain, worn teaspoon with no clear mark is usually valued close to its silver. Before you sell a set by weight, look up the maker’s mark, or show the pieces to an antiques dealer who handles American silver. See melt value vs collector value.

Before you sell

  • Don’t polish heavily or try to remove engraving. Both can lower collector value.
  • Get two or three offers, and ask each buyer what they pay per gram for coin silver and for sterling. See how to tell if an offer is fair.
  • Selling silver for more than you paid for it can be taxable. Inherited pieces have their own rules. See do you pay taxes when you sell gold?

These values are estimates of the silver content, not offers or financial advice. Buyers set their own prices.

Sources

Last reviewed November 17, 2026. This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Was this guide helpful?

Keep reading

All guides →