Bid and ask prices: why dealers buy for less than they sell

What bid, ask and spread mean on a dealer's price board, why the gap exists, and how to use it to judge an offer for your gold or silver.

Quick answer

The ask is the price a dealer sells at and the bid is the price they buy at. The gap between them, called the spread, covers the dealer's costs and profit, so you'll usually be offered less than the price you see for buying the same item.

Two prices for the same coin

If you look up a gold coin on a dealer’s website, you might see a price of a few thousand dollars. Then you call to sell the same coin and the offer is lower. That isn’t necessarily a trick. Almost every dealer quotes two prices:

  • Ask (or “sell” price): what the dealer charges when you buy from them.
  • Bid (or “buy” price): what the dealer pays when you sell to them.

The difference between the two is called the spread. The spread is how a dealer covers rent, staff, insurance, testing, shipping and profit.

The words can be confusing because they are from the dealer’s point of view. When a sign says “We buy at” and “We sell at”, the “We buy at” number is the one that matters to you as a seller.

How bid and ask relate to spot

Spot is the market price for one troy ounce of pure metal traded in bulk. It is the number you see on financial news. Read more in spot vs scrap price.

For common bullion, both prices usually sit around spot:

  • The ask is usually above spot, because the dealer adds a markup (often called a premium) for making, shipping and storing the coin or bar.
  • The bid is usually at or below spot, because the dealer needs room to resell it.

So the full spread is the dealer’s markup on top of spot plus whatever they take off when buying. Two dealers can both say they pay “near spot” and still give you quite different amounts.

Why some items have wider spreads

The spread isn’t the same for everything. It tends to be narrowest on items a dealer can resell quickly and is sure are genuine, and widest on items that take time, testing or refining.

Item Spread is usually Why
Well-known 1 oz bullion coins and bars Narrowest Easy to recognize, test and resell
Small coins and fractional sizes Wider per ounce More handling cost for less metal
Worn 90% US silver coins Varies with demand Priced by face value; see junk silver
Scrap jewelry Widest Needs testing and refining before resale

Spreads also widen when prices move fast. When the market is jumpy, dealers protect themselves by paying a little less and charging a little more.

What this means when you sell

The spread explains why an offer can look low next to a “price” you found online. Before you decide whether an offer is fair, check which price you’re comparing it to:

  • A dealer’s ask price is not what your item is worth to a seller. Comparing an offer to it will always make the offer look bad.
  • Melt value (pure metal content times spot) is a better starting point. Our calculator and coin values pages show melt value.
  • The dealer’s posted bid is the best comparison of all, because it’s what they say they’ll pay.

How to use the spread to your advantage

  • Ask for the bid, not the ask. Many bullion dealers post buy prices. If they don’t, ask “What do you pay for this today?”
  • Ask how the price is worked out. A buyer who pays based on spot should be able to tell you roughly how far below spot their bid is.
  • Compare like with like. Get quotes on the same day for the same items, since spot changes through the day.
  • Know your item. Common bullion usually gets the tightest spread. Coins that may be worth more to collectors are a separate question; see melt value vs collector value.
  • Use the offer checker. Enter an offer in the calculator to see what share of melt value it is.

A narrow spread usually means a dealer that trades in volume. A very wide one isn’t proof of a bad buyer, but it is a good reason to get a second quote. For more tips, see how to tell if a gold offer is fair.

These are general explanations, not financial advice. Prices and dealer policies change, so always confirm the current offer before you sell.

Last reviewed November 12, 2026. This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Was this guide helpful?

Keep reading

All guides →